Indianapolis Handmade Cheesecake
Located in Indianapolis
Located just two blocks from the famous Indy 500, Grammy Sue's offers handmade cheesecake to the Greater Indianapolis Area. Located at 3635 W. 16th Street.
Made from an old family recipe, and made by hand, we take pride in our small batch process that ensures quality every time.
Our Legendary Variety 6 pack
Mix and match any way you want to create your own 6 pack pie! Similar to how you buy donuts, you can get mix n match to accommodate any situation. Perfect for office parties and events.
Need a Whole Pie?
We specialize in custom 9" cheesecakes. Offered in a variety of flavors.....we even cater to new ideas. We've made maple bacon cheesecakes, cookie dough, Pumpkin Pie...the sky's the limit! All of our pies are custom ordered and we typically have it ready next day or you.
Cherry Cheesecake
A Grammy Sue's Classic and the best Cherry Cheesecake you'll ever eat! Made by hand in Indianapolis, IN, this cheesecake and thick graham cracker crust is a piece of heaven. Topped with Cherries, you'll be glad you tried it. Available in Full Pies and Individual Slices!
Country Strawberry
A Grammy Sue's Cheesecake Classic. Made by hand in Indianapolis, IN, this cheesecake and thick graham cracker crust is a piece of heaven. Topped with Strawberries. You've had NY Style Strawberry...now try the best country style cheesecake in Indiana! Available in Full Pies and Individual Slices!
Plain Cheesecake
A Grammy Sue's Classic. Made by hand in Indianapolis, IN, this cheesecake and thick graham cracker crust is a piece of heaven. Available in Full Pies and Individual Slices!
Classic Blueberry
A Grammy Sue's Classic. Made by hand in Indianapolis, IN, this cheesecake and thick graham cracker crust is a piece of heaven. Topped with Blueberries, you'll be glad you tried it. Available in Full Pies and Individual Slices!
Caramel Chocolate
A Grammy Sue's Classic. Made by hand in Indianapolis, IN, this cheesecake and thick graham cracker crust is a piece of heaven. Topped with Blueberries, you'll be glad you tried it. Available in Full Pies and Individual Slices!
Lemon Blueberry
A Grammy Sue's Specialty Flavor. Made by hand in Indianapolis, IN, this cheesecake is a piece of heaven. A lemon flavored cheesecake topped with Blueberries. Available in Individual Slices!
Peanut butter & Jelly
A Grammy Sue's Specialty Flavor. Made by hand in Indianapolis, IN, this cheesecake is a piece of heaven. A peanut butter flavored cheesecake topped with strawberries! Taste like the classic PBnJ sandwich. Available in Individual Slices!
Banana Split
A Grammy Sue's Specialty Flavor. Made by hand in Indianapolis, IN, this cheesecake is a great spin on the classic Banana Split. A banana flavored cheesecake topped with pineapple strawberries and drizzled with chocolate syrup! Available in Individual Slices!
Double Chocolate
Made in Indianapolis , this A Grammy Sue's Cheesecake is a Must Try Specialty Flavor. A chocolate flavored cheesecake topped with chocolate pieces and syrup. Available in Individual Slices!
Reece Cup
Made by hand in Indianapolis, IN, this cheesecake is a piece of heaven. A plain or peanut butter flavored cheesecake topped with Reece Cup. Available in Individual Slices!
-
I Love it!
"I love this Cheesecake! I've had it since I was a child and there's nothing better than a creamy bite of blueberry!"
-
Thank You!
"Thank you for your donation to our annual teacher appreciation luncheon. Everybody loved your cheeecake and it went very fast."
-
For the Holidays
Christmas and Thanksgiving aren't the same without Grammy Sue's Cheesecake! Originally served half cherry and half blueberry, the cheesecake was always the hit of the meal.